A thought experiment

[xoder]

Can you think of any cause that is (in your not-so-humble opinion) morally or logically right and is not an underdog?

Comments

[faboo.livejournal.com]

I'm under the distinct belief that this is not generally justifiable.

certainly, the flu can be devastating to someone with a compromised or not-so-functional immune system (like the elderly, says the TeeVee), but for most people it just means getting rather sick. in fact, I think that for most people, getting a flu shot is a convenience like 24-hour drug stores: they aren't necessary, but they let you use each hour of your day effectively and efficiently.

it's good to get sick occasionally; it builds character. the flu isn't a serious condition unless you've already got one, so we ought to just grow up and deal with it.

[xoder.livejournal.com]

That's not entirely true. There have been influenza epidemics in the past that have killed thousands. We just haven't had any lately.

Then the question is: is it the flu shots, or just a general higher standard of living that has kept us relatively safe?